Our Bodies, Our Blog

In the Fight Against HIV, Gendered Assumptions Have Deadly Consequences

By OBOS |
A bottle of Descovy for PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis)

By Charlotte Babbin

In October 2019, the FDA approval of the new HIV-prevention drug Descovy was met with great excitement by doctors, HIV researchers, and many people at risk of HIV infection. Descovy functions as a pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), medicine taken to prevent HIV infection. The second ever drug approved for PrEP, in research trials, Descovy reduced kidney and bone health side effects.

Not everyone, however, applauded the approval of this drug. To many people’s disappointment, Descovy was not approved for use by people assigned female at birth (AFAB), including cisgender women, trans men, and AFAB folks of other genders. Descovy’s safety and efficacy trials excluded these groups of people. While many were disappointed, they were not surprised. Drug companies have left the AFAB community out of HIV-related clinical trials before. Most likely, this time will not be the last, a fact that leaves many wondering when medical research will match the reality of the HIV epidemic.

Historical assumptions that HIV/AIDS is a disease that mostly affects gay and bisexual men has shaped the way medical professionals and drug companies have responded. In the early 1980s, cisgender women were not diagnosed with AIDS because physicians considered it a man’s disease. Throughout the decade, despite rising cases in cisgender women, prevention research focused on male-centered approaches, and women were excluded from medical trials.

Today, while over half of people living with HIV worldwide are women, the assumption that men bear most of the burden of HIV remains prevalent in modern discourse, clinical trials, and prevention research. As of 2016, women made up only 11% of participants in clinical trials of potential HIV cures and only 19% of participants in antiretroviral trials. According to Dr. Eileen Scully, assistant professor of medicine at Johns Hopkins University, it is difficult to convince many scientists to take seriously the need to enroll women in clinical trials. “Some of the hard scientists dismiss this type of discussion as being more socially determined, or some sort of women’s liberation thing,” she explained.

Research, however, shows that the biological response to HIV differs between the male and female sexes. In fact, HIV progresses faster to AIDS in females, and they are more likely to have heart attacks and strokes. HIV treatment and prevention drugs need to work for people of all sexes and genders, which starts with researchers prioritizing the recruitment of women to clinical trials.

For AFAB trans folks, including trans men and gender nonbinary people, the problem is even more severe. Inaccurate assumptions that they only have sex with cisgender women and engage less frequently in behaviors that increase HIV risk have not only led AFAB trans folks to be underrepresented in HIV-related clinical trials, but have also led to extreme undersurveillance of HIV spread throughout these populations. The CDC’s annual HIV Surveillance Report publishes vast amounts of data about HIV diagnoses and deaths, yet did not include any data about transgender folks until 2019. Even in the more recent reports, the amount of data published about trans folks is slim compared to that of cisgender folks (particularly cisgender men).

Furthermore, the CDC’s section on HIV and Transgender People includes very little information about trans men and no acknowledgement of nonbinary people. “AFAB trans people are still not recognized enough by researchers and health care providers to investigate the specific risks to our community or to offer us medically appropriate and accessible care,” explains trans activist and HIV researcher Max Appenroth in the book No Data No More, which he co-authored. “If we aren’t being discriminated against or even attacked,” Appenroth continues, “I and my community live with missing knowledge on the side of doctors or a lack of information based on insufficient research.” It is therefore imperative that medical professionals dedicate greater time and attention to studying HIV among AFAB trans folks.

Assumptions that cisgender women and AFAB trans folks are not at risk of HIV have deadly consequences. It is these assumptions that allow pharmaceutical companies to underrepresent these groups in clinical trials or leave them out altogether. These assumptions also cause cis women and AFAB trans folks to often perceive themselves as not at risk of HIV. Compounded by the fact that many doctors are influenced by this same belief, this perception makes AFAB folks less likely to be interested in and prescribed PrEP. In fact, in 2018 only 7% of women and AFAB trans people in the U.S. who were considered at risk of HIV were prescribed PrEP. Women and AFAB trans folks are not getting the protection they need from HIV infection.

We need to change the status quo about HIV. It is essential for researchers to put in the effort to recruit a substantial number of women and AFAB trans people in clinical trials for all HIV-related drugs. It is similarly important to include women and AFAB trans folks in conversations about HIV. Surveillance reports of HIV cases must also collect more data about transgender people, especially AFAB trans people, whose HIV cases have been greatly understudied. If the global HIV epidemic is to ever end, we need HIV research that is free from the biases and injustices that have fueled the persistence of this deadly disease.

Charlotte Babbin is a student at Wesleyan University and intern for Our Bodies Ourselves Today. Set to launch in 2022, Our Bodies Ourselves Today is an online platform created by the Center for Women’s Health & Human Rights at Suffolk University in partnership with Our Bodies Ourselves that is dedicated to providing women, girls, and gender-diverse people with comprehensive health information.

Banner reading "UNITED FOR 🌢 PERIOD PARITY".Banner reading "UNITED FOR 🌢 PERIOD PARITY".

Period Poverty is a Human Rights Issue. Period.

By Guest Contributor |

by Hannah Sachs-Wetstone

What is period poverty?

Let’s talk about period poverty. Period poverty occurs when menstruators cannot access the menstrual products, underwear, and pain medication they need to maintain their menstrual health due to a variety of factors, such as cost, stigma, and gender discrimination. Globally, there are 1.8 billion people who menstruate and 500 million people who do not have the ability to maintain their menstrual health.

Menstrual health is a human rights issue. All those who menstruate have the right to the knowledge, … More

Stopping Keystone: A Victory for Native Women’s Health

By Guest Contributor |

By Hannah Sachs-Wetstone

In early June, after more than ten years of conflict, the Keystone XL oil pipeline project was halted by TC Energy, the company behind the project. This is a victory for Indigenous communities and environmental activists. However, the fight for justice is not over.

The destruction of tribal lands is fueled by the assault on Indigenous peoples’ — especially indigenous women’s — bodies. While the halting of the Keystone pipeline is an important step, many challenges remain: the Murdered and Missing Women … More

Logo for Our Bodies Ourselves TodayLogo for Our Bodies Ourselves Today

Celebrate Pride Month with a #GiveOUTDay donation to Our Bodies Ourselves Today!

By Guest Contributor |

by Hannah Sachs-Wetstone 

Our Bodies Ourselves Today, a new online platform featuring up-to-date information about health, sexuality, and well-being, is set to launch in 2022. The platform is being created by the Center for Women’s Health & Human Rights at Suffolk University in partnership with Our Bodies Ourselves. The post below was written by Hannah Sachs-Wetstone, an intern on the project.

Our Bodies Ourselves Today is running a #GiveOUTDay campaign throughout Pride Month! The OBOS Today platform will be a global, world-class resource … More

close up of antidepressant pillsclose up of antidepressant pills

When Antidepressants Leave Lasting Damage: Living with Post-SSRI/SNRI Sexual Dysfunction

By Guest Contributor |

by Emily Grey

My clitoris is now no more than an inert and sensation-less nub of flesh. I am unable to feel attraction, arousal or orgasm.… The effects of losing my sexuality have been absolutely devastating to my relationships and mental health. I have been robbed of an essential aspect of my humanity.” – Emily, age 24, PSSD 2 years

Sexuality is an integral part of our lives, central to our identity, our quality of life, and the ways we connect with other human beings. So what … More

addyi prescriptionaddyi prescription

False or Misleading Claims: More Problems with Addyi

By Guest Contributor |

by Marshall Miller and Dorian Solot

The so-called “pink Viagra” drug Addyi (flibanserin) is in the news again. This time, Sprout Pharmaceuticals, the drug’s manufacturer, is being called out by the FDA for making “false or misleading claims about the risks associated with Addyi.”

OBOS has previously written about how the health risks of the drug outweigh its benefits. The FDA approved Addyi in 2015, after Sprout Pharmaceuticals, the drug’s manufacturer, engaged in an aggressive marketing campaign designed to convince people that it was only fair … More

Persistent and Pervasive: Feminists Take on Toxics

By Judy Norsigian |

For a variety of reasons, including gendered work and home experiences, women face different environmental health risks than men. Women are more likely to use personal care products, cosmetics, and cleaning products, and therefore more likely to face daily exposure to the toxic chemicals in many consumer products. As awareness of toxic chemicals has increased, feminist scientists and activists are drawing attention to the real adverse health risks they pose and have mobilized to work toward creative and radical solutions.

Sally Edwards, an environmental health scientist, … More

Diana Abwoye receiving an award for academic excellence in her Family Nurse Practitioner program.Diana Abwoye receiving an award for academic excellence in her Family Nurse Practitioner program.

Addressing Institutional Racism & Health Inequality: My Perspective

By Guest Contributor |

by Diana Namumbejja Abwoye

Diana Namumbejja Abwoye is a family nurse practitioner and a member of the Board of Directors of Our Bodies Ourselves who translated and adapted “Our Bodies, Ourselves” into Luganda.

Covid-19 has affected all aspects of our lives. It has exposed how much the United States is an unequal place for people of color. I will speak here from my own experience. It may not be a reflection of all people of color, but I hope it will help us get the … More

Adapting “Our Bodies, Ourselves” to Brazilian Portuguese: The Translators’ Experiences

By OBOS |

“[H]aving the opportunity of translating … “Our Bodies, Ourselves” to Brazilian Portuguese … brings me a profound sense of accomplishment, since there is not such a complete book on women’s health in Portuguese with so much information and so many references…. When we translate, we must consider the cultural identity of the women we are talking to, the means of reaching them, which information they need to have safer and more conscient lives. Each translation choice is also a political choice, inspired by reflections on … More